EDHdad wrote: So what does blue offer green, if not removal and card draw? **** creatures?? Blue offers tempo. ......
EDHdad wrote: So what does blue offer green, if not removal and card draw? **** creatures?? Blue offers tempo. Imagine a blue deck with a Sigiled Starfish on the field, and the next 100 cards in the deck are all Disperse. Now imagine a green deck with Skysnare Spider on the field, 5 Skysnare Spiders in hand and the next 100 cards in the deck are also Skysnare Spider. Suppose blue gets 4 mana per turn, while green gets 6 mana per turn. Blue's turns would look like this: Bounce the spider, attack for 3. Green's turns would look like this: Cast the spider for 6, no attacks, pass turn. Blue will eventually win that game even though their creature has less power and they receive less mana per turn. Now, imagine green gets all rampy, and generates 18 mana per turn, while blue still generates 4 mana per turn. Blue bounces the spider, hits for 3. Green casts 2 spiders, has a 12/12 spider on the field, passes turn. Blue bounces the spider, hits for 3. That's tempo. Blue is using one card and 4 mana to undo what green is doing with 2 cards and 18 mana.
Rootbreaker wrote: In the scenario where green's only card is spider, they can't have just played a spider and have 6 cards in their hand.
EDHdad wrote: I actually just went through a game like this. I was playing my Jace deck. The opponent was a very good Nissa deck who kept getting cascade after cascade after cascade and vomiting their hand. They cast an Outland Colossus. I bounced it with Harbinger of the Tides. They had a reinforced Herald of the Pantheon, 8/8. I used Jace's first ability to reduce it to a 3/8, then Tightening Coils to make it a 0/8. Then I hit it with Breaker of Armies to kill it. They cast Gaea's Revenge, which has hexproof and haste. It hit me for 9. Then the next turn, my Breaker of Armies collided with the Gaea's Revenge and they both died. At one point they cascaded so much that they got 30 loyalty. Next turn they turned 24 gems to green, which ended up casting 2 Outland Colossus. I bounced it with Disperse, then used Talent of the Telepath to find Day's Undoing and shuffled it away. They cast Dwynen, Gilt-Leaf Daen. I bounced it. They recast it. I turned it into a frog and then bounced the frog. They looked like they were going to cast something really big, maybe another Gaea's Revenge. They had maybe one or two mana left to go and then I cast Day's Undoing to shuffle it away. Eventually I won the game with an 8-power Harbinger of Tides and a 9-power Sigiled Starfish. I'm sure that if I were piloting that green deck and if the AI was piloting my blue deck, I would have also beaten the AI, since the AI doesn't really sequence cards correctly, never discards to their advantage, never turns off spells so they can cast them at the opportune time, and such. However, reports of Blue's death are greatly exaggerated. A halfway decent Jace deck can rack up 50 to 100 wins in a row or more.